WIP Windows 3D MVC Bluray test builds - Printable Version +- Kodi Community Forum (https://forum.kodi.tv) +-- Forum: Development (https://forum.kodi.tv/forumdisplay.php?fid=32) +--- Forum: Kodi Application (https://forum.kodi.tv/forumdisplay.php?fid=93) +--- Thread: WIP Windows 3D MVC Bluray test builds (/showthread.php?tid=265299) |
RE: Windows 3D MVC Bluray test builds - UnoDeTantos - 2016-03-23 Zotac ID18 (celeron 1007u) with windows 10 / 8.1 and last test build, works!!! ... but the image on right eye moves up and down all the time (tested with 5 movies in mkv mvc) Thanks!!!!! PS: YCbCr Mode RE: Windows 3D MVC Bluray test builds - dchabby - 2016-03-23 (2016-03-23, 01:17)UnoDeTantos Wrote: Zotac ID18 (celeron 1007u) with windows 10 / 8.1 and last test build, works!!! ... but the image on right eye moves up and down all the time (tested with 5 movies in mkv mvc) sounds like the same issue I have with my Celeron 2957U. Im upgrading now from windows 8.1 to 10 just to see if that makes any difference. Not really expecting it to but I was planning on upgrading anyway so will see if it makes a difference RE: Windows 3D MVC Bluray test builds - afedchin - 2016-03-23 (2016-03-23, 00:31)movie78 Wrote: Ok! I disable 3D Stream,played the same file in 2D and there was no lip-sync issue.Ok. Try to set the Render method to DXVA. Settings->Video->Acceleration. RE: Windows 3D MVC Bluray test builds - movie78 - 2016-03-23 (2016-03-23, 07:27)afedchin Wrote:(2016-03-23, 00:31)movie78 Wrote: Ok! I disable 3D Stream,played the same file in 2D and there was no lip-sync issue.Ok. Try to set the Render method to DXVA. Settings->Video->Acceleration. DXVA is always turn on, do you want me to turn it off? RE: Windows 3D MVC Bluray test builds - afedchin - 2016-03-23 @movie78 you are confusing between DXVA decoding and DXVA rendering. There is the setting named Render method, by default it has Auto value. I meant to set value of this setting to DXVA. Don't touch Allow hardware acceleration - DXVA2 it doesn't matter for MVC. RE: Windows 3D MVC Bluray test builds - movie78 - 2016-03-23 (2016-03-23, 13:20)afedchin Wrote: @movie78 Went from Auto Detect to DXVA and had the same results ( Audio out sync) DXVA 3D Audio out of Sync RE: Windows 3D MVC Bluray test builds - afedchin - 2016-03-23 (2016-03-23, 13:35)movie78 Wrote: Went from Auto Detect to DXVA and had the same results ( Audio out sync)You are still using Pixel shader. from your log Quote:CWinRenderer::SelectRenderMethod: Selected render method 1: Pixel Shadersor you uploaded wrong log. RE: Windows 3D MVC Bluray test builds - movie78 - 2016-03-23 (2016-03-23, 13:40)afedchin Wrote:(2016-03-23, 13:35)movie78 Wrote: Went from Auto Detect to DXVA and had the same results ( Audio out sync)You are still using Pixel shader. from your log DXVA only DXVA 3D RE: Windows 3D MVC Bluray test builds - afedchin - 2016-03-23 (2016-03-23, 13:40)movie78 Wrote: DXVA onlyDoes sync issue occur with DXVA? RE: Windows 3D MVC Bluray test builds - SofaKng - 2016-03-23 (2016-03-22, 21:57)Statikk Wrote: @SofaKng Off topic, but I'm wondering what the name of your IP remote system is.I'm using URC's Total Control system. It's a bit expensive but allows full programming of everything including 12v triggers, RS-232, IR, IP, etc. RE: Windows 3D MVC Bluray test builds - movie78 - 2016-03-23 (2016-03-23, 14:10)afedchin Wrote:(2016-03-23, 13:40)movie78 Wrote: DXVA onlyDoes sync issue occur with DXVA? Yes!! RE: Windows 3D MVC Bluray test builds - movie78 - 2016-03-23 (2016-03-22, 01:53)hdmkv Wrote: @movie78, can you test 'Rio' or 'Drive Angry' on your DN2820 NUC and report back if you get the pixellation I did? Ok! I ran @hdmkv test 3D MVC file on my PC with PowerDVD and there was no Pixellation,On Kodi 17 on the same PC, had pixelation issue. I don't think there is problem with Rip RE: Windows 3D MVC Bluray test builds - Karnis - 2016-03-23 Sharing quickly a couple of thoughts concerning my experiences on GT720 Geforce card/ Win10 64/ THE latest nVidia drivers & March 15 build...audio sync has been my biggest issue, next would be dropped frames, skips/ mini freezes. Most of this happens trying digital audio, so if I let KODI decode the HD audio tracks to the 5.1 analog outputs on my SB sound card, playback is darn near perfect except for the occasional video freeze/audio keeps playing/video catches back up issue. Another thing I've noted, when enabling 3D mode in nVidia control, 23/24 Hz is no longer available in NON 3D mode. Okay, no problem. I can set the desktop to 1920x1080 @ 60Hz, and Kodi will switch the refresh rate to 23/24 Hz at the start of playback. EXCEPT, if you leave your desktop @ 60 Hz & Kodi switches to 23/24 Hz, playback has a hard time syncing up in the beginning of the movie. I know this because since I let Kodi decode the audio & I enable "sync playback to monitor", I hear major pitch shift happening as Kodi struggles to sync audio to video. HOWEVER, if I leave the desktop @ 1920x1080p @ 23/24 Hz, the start of the same movie starts perfectly in sync, no pitch shift, no nothing, and video glitches/ minor freezes are kept to a minimum. My job is killing me right now & I have limited time, so I promise in the next couple of days I'll get some more details & debug logs posted for you. I'll be glad to test builds when I can for the Geforce users out there. Your hard work on this project is greatly appreciated, thanks! RE: Windows 3D MVC Bluray test builds - hdmkv - 2016-03-24 (2016-03-23, 18:02)movie78 Wrote: I ran @hdmkv test 3D MVC file on my PC with PowerDVD and there was no Pixellation,On Kodi 17 on the same PC, had pixelation issue. Thanks for testing @movie78. I'm suspecting it's a Kodi 3D rendering issue... via Intel, via Pi2/3 and via custom Kodi solutions like Zidoo/HiMedia (RK3368). Like I mentioned, the sample I provided above was originally ripped w/MakeMKV to MVC MKV, then later remuxed to 3D ISO via tsMuxeR. Not re-encoded, but simply a container shift. Most of my Blu-ray's are in an off-site storage as I haven't needed them since originally ripping... who the heck out of us wants to keep 100's or 1000's of physical discs around anyway?! . Was hoping Intel NUC w/Windows MVC Kodi builds would play everything. I have 230+ 3D movies, and likely 70% of them would be affected being remuxes. Was hoping I could avoid testing every of my 3D titles via Intel, figuring out which are affected by pixellation, going to storage, hauling all those discs back, and re-ripping. Ugh! Major PITA... as I'd need to re-figure out correct playlist, forced subs to do the movie-only ISO's I do. Bottom line is remuxes should work as well as the straight rips because the original video and audio streams, chapters & PGS are still all there as is from the original discs. I sometimes also do remuxes for example if I want an ATMOS track only available on a 2D BD (for example: 'Gravity') w/MVC video track from 3D BD, getting the best of both worlds. Or, I find a 3D import w/o English audio and buy a 2D English BD, whose track I want to extract and use to create a new 3D ISO. Anyway, here are my findings with 7x different media players w/the 3D ISO of 'Drive Angry', same as sample linked above:
So, for 3D mode playback, the same pixellation issue in players w/integrated Kodi (Intel, Pi3, H8), but in non-Kodi players, no issues. And 2D mode in Shield w/internal Kodi playback, no issue. So, something is up with handling of certain remuxed 3D BD's in Intel/Pi builds. Here's a short (7+ minutes) video showing playback in 5 of the 7 media boxes listed above:
RE: Windows 3D MVC Bluray test builds - wesk05 - 2016-03-24 (2016-03-24, 01:04)hdmkv Wrote: I'm suspecting it's a Kodi 3D rendering issue... via Intel, via Pi2/3 and via custom Kodi solutions like Zidoo/HiMedia (RK3368). Like I mentioned, the sample I provided above was originally ripped w/MakeMKV to MVC MKV, then later remuxed to 3D ISO via tsMuxeR. Not re-encoded, but simply a container shift.I didn't get pixelation when I converted your sample ISO to MVC MKV in MakeMKV. So, the problem may not be with the actual m2ts files. It may have to do with the Blu-ray file structure created by tsMuxeR. |