[schumi2004]

I wasn't sure were to put this issue but general PVR support looked logical for me.

Recently i'm using comskip to generate the needed EDL files to use in XBMC, all working perfect and tested it a few times without issues.
But then i asked my girlfriend if see noticed anything with the new feature in my setup and see said NO!
I was like huh ?
So i tested and activated debug logging and noticed this.

The way i tested it was browse in file manager and play recording.
The way my girlfriend watches recording is using the build in recordings tab from GUI and there it fails.

When playing file using file manager/browser you'll see this. (notice the file path/type)

Code:

22:57:30 T:139791790208768  NOTICE: Thread DVDPlayerAudio start, auto delete: false
22:57:30 T:139791790208768  NOTICE: running thread: CDVDPlayerAudio::Process()
22:57:30 T:139791781816064   DEBUG: ReadEditDecisionLists - Checking for edit decision lists (EDL) on local drive or remote share for: nfs://10.0.0.100/volume1/recordings/Goede-tijden,-slechte-tijden/RTL-4-Goede-tijden,-slechte-tijden.2013-04-25.20-00.mkv
22:57:30 T:139791781816064   DEBUG: CNFSFile::Open - opened volume1/recordings/Goede-tijden,-slechte-tijden/RTL-4-Goede-tijden,-slechte-tijden.2013-04-25.20-00.edl
22:57:30 T:139791781816064   DEBUG: AddCut - Pushing new cut to back [00:00:00.000 - 00:01:55.240], 0
22:57:30 T:139791781816064   DEBUG: AddCut - Pushing new cut to back [00:17:18.040 - 00:24:04.280], 0
22:57:30 T:139791781816064   DEBUG: AddCut - Pushing new cut to back [00:36:44.600 - 00:37:19.160], 0
22:57:30 T:139791781816064   DEBUG: CNFSFile::Close closing file volume1/recordings/Goede-tijden,-slechte-tijden/RTL-4-Goede-tijden,-slechte-tijden.2013-04-25.20-00.edl
22:57:30 T:139791781816064   DEBUG: ReadEdl - Read 3 cuts and 0 scene markers in EDL file: nfs://10.0.0.100/volume1/recordings/Goede-tijden,-slechte-tijden/RTL-4-Goede-tijden,-slechte-tijden.2013-04-25.20-00.edl
22:57:30 T:139791781816064   DEBUG: WriteMPlayerEdl - MPlayer EDL file written to: special://temp/xbmc.edl
22:57:30 T:139791781816064   DEBUG: Process - Start position set to end of first cut or commercial break: 115240
22:

EDL Found and working!

When playing with recordings tab from GUI you'll see this (again notice the file type/path)

Code:

22:55:16 T:139791592593152   DEBUG: ReadEditDecisionLists - Checking for edit decision list (EDL) for PVR recording: pvr://recordings//Goede-tijden,-slechte-tijden/Goede tijden, slechte tijden, TV (RTL 4), 20130425_180000.pvr
22:55:16 T:139791592593152   DEBUG: ReadPvr - Reading Edl for recording: Goede tijden, slechte tijden
22:55:16 T:139791592593152   DEBUG: CDVDPlayer::SetCaching - caching state 3
22:55:16 T:139791621134080   DEBUG: CDVDPlayerAudio - CDVDMsg::GENERAL_RESYNC(4000.000000, 0)

NO EDL file is found!

Is this something i can solve or is this a XBMC issue or maybe a TVHeadend one?

I'm using latest TVHeadend as backend.

[Prof Yaffle]

It's not supported. I believe that the difference is that when browsing to the file, XBMC can look around, find the EDL file and load it; when playing through the Recordings function, XBMC can't see the file directly (i.e. the containing directory isn't exported or mounted by the client in any way) and so it's the backend that streams the file over to XBMC.