+- Kodi Community Forum (https://forum.kodi.tv)
+-- Forum: Development (https://forum.kodi.tv/forumdisplay.php?fid=32)
+--- Forum: Feature Discussion (read-only) (https://forum.kodi.tv/forumdisplay.php?fid=183)
+--- Thread: Solved "Okay" button is at the bottom, but pressing down does not reach it (/showthread.php?tid=153416)
Pages:
1
2
"Okay" button is at the bottom, but pressing down does not reach it - Ned Scott - 2013-01-13
Problem: Sometimes in Confluence an "Okay" button is physically at the bottom of a screen, but pressing down does not reach it. Instead, the user has to press right or left. Occasionally I even get tripped up on this still and for a moment go "wtf, why is it not going down?"
Solution: Not really sure. Maybe make the "okay" button say something like:
"<-- = Okay" (though that's still not actually true, since you still have to press select for it to actually press Okay).
I'm sure there's lots of little GUI improvements that could be done and tweaked and all that, but this one in particular has always bugged me.
[splitjm4] Polishing our diamond, interaction discussion - jmarshall - 2013-01-23
Quote:Problem: Sometimes in Confluence an "Okay" button is physically at the bottom of a screen, but pressing down does not reach it. Instead, the user has to press right or left. Occasionally I even get tripped up on this still and for a moment go "wtf, why is it not going down?"
Solution: Not really sure. Maybe make the "okay" button say something like:
This is normally due to lists being used where a dropdown or combobox type thing would be more appropriate. If you screenshot the areas, we can focus the brainstorming.
[split] Sometimes in Confluence an "Okay" button is physically at the bottom of a screen, but - Ned Scott - 2013-01-25
Here's one.
RE: "Okay" button is at the bottom, but pressing down does not reach it - Ned Scott - 2013-03-29
http://forum.xbmc.org/showthread.php?tid=160775
Also, that whole "not seeing files when adding a source" really throws users, too. They come to the fair conclusion that if nothing is listed then something is wrong.
RE: "Okay" button is at the bottom, but pressing down does not reach it - jmarshall - 2013-03-30
If they could reach OK they wouldn't really have had an issue with the lack of listing I think?
Ideally the OK/Cancel need to be on the left (or right) of the list near the top.
RE: "Okay" button is at the bottom, but pressing down does not reach it - Ned Scott - 2013-03-30
I went through some of the skins we have on the XBMC repo and found 4 that take that approach. Perhaphs one of these could serve as inspiration?
Metropolis:
reFocus BIG (not on the XBMC.org repo, but a really nice skin):
XeeBo:
xTV-SAF:
RE: "Okay" button is at the bottom, but pressing down does not reach it - natethomas - 2013-12-06
Ping on this in light of this thread.
http://forum.xbmc.org/showthread.php?tid=179514
It's obviously up to the release managers how much skin-exclusive change we make to Confluence from the 10th on, but the UPnP fixes and moving the OK/Cancel buttons to the left of the lists both seem like extremely useful "simple" fixes that would dramatically benefit UX. @ronie or @BigNoid , any thoughts?
RE: "Okay" button is at the bottom, but pressing down does not reach it - jjd-uk - 2013-12-07
From the above I think XeeBo has it most intuative way, which is select left then action right, IMHO I think this is the most natural way since most cultures read left to right therefore your workflow should be left to right.
RE: "Okay" button is at the bottom, but pressing down does not reach it - ronie - 2013-12-07
something like this ?
RE: "Okay" button is at the bottom, but pressing down does not reach it - Ned Scott - 2013-12-07
I like it!
RE: "Okay" button is at the bottom, but pressing down does not reach it - natethomas - 2013-12-07
That'd definitely work for me. I assume the navigation is switched from moving left to moving right? Or alternatively, it can go both ways?
RE: "Okay" button is at the bottom, but pressing down does not reach it - jjd-uk - 2013-12-07
Looks perfect to me
RE: "Okay" button is at the bottom, but pressing down does not reach it - topfs2 - 2013-12-07
Looks awesome
RE: "Okay" button is at the bottom, but pressing down does not reach it - BigNoid - 2013-12-07
I think the art work is a bit too small in the filebrowser. How about this:
RE: "Okay" button is at the bottom, but pressing down does not reach it - da-anda - 2013-12-07
I'd make the "browse for source" dialog narrower, people with file and foldernames that long that they needed such long lines need to be punished
Also, while the positioning is somewhat fine, I don't like that you don't recognize the buttons right away as such (mabe it's just the screenshots, don't know). I see two solutions to this: give buttons a different color (blue maybe) or give the the column they reside in a slightly different background color (greyish maybe)
edit: @BigNoid
looks like a bit too much of wasted space