Kodi Community Forum
Bug [BUG] (or intentional?) Subtitle checkbox missing on embedded subs - Printable Version

Kodi Community Forum (https://forum.kodi.tv)
+-- Forum: Support (https://forum.kodi.tv/forumdisplay.php?fid=33)
+--- Forum: Supplementary Tools for Kodi (https://forum.kodi.tv/forumdisplay.php?fid=116)
+---- Forum: Ember Media Manager (https://forum.kodi.tv/forumdisplay.php?fid=195)
---- Thread: Bug [BUG] (or intentional?) Subtitle checkbox missing on embedded subs (/showthread.php?tid=166234)



[BUG] (or intentional?) Subtitle checkbox missing on embedded subs - Christian042 - 2013-06-02

Using the latest Ember Media Manager, it ticks the tick when there are external subtitles but not embedded subtitles, so I'm kinda wondering if this is a bug or somehow intentional.

PS. I've looked through the topics and have not seen this mentioned, so if this is a duplicate, I apologize.


RE: [BUG] (or intentional?) Subtitle checkbox missing on embedded subs - m.savazzi - 2013-06-02

I think we are not able to detect internal subtitles. External ones are easy because we look for files with same name of the video and SRT or other extension. But for the embedded subtitles there is no check.

If you discover how to check the embedded subtitles we can improve the code.


RE: [BUG] (or intentional?) Subtitle checkbox missing on embedded subs - Christian042 - 2013-06-02

Can't you process the metadata and grab the info from there?

Because the metadata finds the embedded subtitles and shows which language they are (if it's embedded correctly)


RE: [BUG] (or intentional?) Subtitle checkbox missing on embedded subs - m.savazzi - 2013-06-02

(2013-06-02, 12:25)Christian042 Wrote: Can't you process the metadata and grab the info from there?

Because the metadata finds the embedded subtitles and shows which language they are (if it's embedded correctly)

which metadata?


RE: [BUG] (or intentional?) Subtitle checkbox missing on embedded subs - Christian042 - 2013-06-02

The one that Ember grabs from the media file

Image


RE: [BUG] (or intentional?) Subtitle checkbox missing on embedded subs - m.savazzi - 2013-06-02

Ha!
was not aware of it!

will try to understand from where that info is grabbed and why is not managed as the other subtitles.

Thank you for highlighting the issue!


RE: [BUG] (or intentional?) Subtitle checkbox missing on embedded subs - ezechiel1917 - 2013-06-03

If you decide to include embedded subtitle to subtitle checkbox please make it optional.
I prefer current situation when it only marks the checkbox when external subtitles exists. Many videos have embedded subtitles I don't really care for and currently when EMM detects only external subtitles I exactly know which media I have subtitles I need. Something which I have actually power to manage compared to timr consuming remux of whole video in case I need to remove embedded subtitles (so I won't have a marked subtitle checkbox).

Thanks!


RE: [BUG] (or intentional?) Subtitle checkbox missing on embedded subs - m.savazzi - 2013-06-07

(2013-06-03, 22:22)ezechiel1917 Wrote: If you decide to include embedded subtitle to subtitle checkbox please make it optional.
I prefer current situation when it only marks the checkbox when external subtitles exists. Many videos have embedded subtitles I don't really care for and currently when EMM detects only external subtitles I exactly know which media I have subtitles I need. Something which I have actually power to manage compared to timr consuming remux of whole video in case I need to remove embedded subtitles (so I won't have a marked subtitle checkbox).

Thanks!

How bugs can be a functionality Smile


RE: [BUG] (or intentional?) Subtitle checkbox missing on embedded subs - Dragen - 2013-06-07

Also, remember that hard subs are merged into the videostream and can't be detected in meta.


RE: [BUG] (or intentional?) Subtitle checkbox missing on embedded subs - m.savazzi - 2013-06-08

Correct,
I was thinking that, maybe, there is a way to detect subs in ISO/DVD folders or in the MKV or Vorbis.


This forum uses Lukasz Tkacz MyBB addons.