Kodi Community Forum
Subtitle handling in OSD - Printable Version

Kodi Community Forum (https://forum.kodi.tv)
+-- Forum: Development (https://forum.kodi.tv/forumdisplay.php?fid=32)
+--- Forum: Feature Discussion (read-only) (https://forum.kodi.tv/forumdisplay.php?fid=183)
--- Thread: Subtitle handling in OSD (/showthread.php?tid=183437)



Subtitle handling in OSD - topfs2 - 2014-01-15

When pressing next in OSD of subtitles in Gotham the subtitle can be disabled. While this makes perfect sense if you have "next" and/or "previous" subtitle mapped to a key on the keyboard/remote, it is frustrating in the GUI. I mean, there is an "enable/disable" button and its not at all clear that the next will do that. Even worse, when you disable it the little popup vanishes Smile

I propose that we add either an option to the [Next|Previous]Subtitle action which allows for disable, or we add another action. It is confusing that it disables in OSD GUI.

Thoughts?


RE: Subtitle handling in OSD - Ace - 2014-01-15

+1


RE: Subtitle handling in OSD - da-anda - 2014-01-15

sure, introduce a new action which only cycles through subtitles but does not disable those and use it in skins. Keep keymappings as they are.


RE: Subtitle handling in OSD - Ned Scott - 2014-01-15

Sounds logical


RE: Subtitle handling in OSD - topfs2 - 2014-01-15

So now to the really hard question, What to name the action Tongue

The current one is NextSubtitle. To me that naming suggest _nothing_ about it disableing subtitles. So IMO that one should perhaps be the one which just selects a subtitle?
The other name I can come up with is CycleSubtitle, not sure if thats a good naming for with disable or without disable? To be frank its quite hard to name it in any way so that it makes perfect sense its a different action and what the intent is Tongue

Thoughts?


RE: Subtitle handling in OSD - topfs2 - 2014-01-15

Very quickly thrown together for the sake of testing it out. https://github.com/topfs2/xbmc/commit/243f6d37e9c2534be3bb35c6ada4cc84a1baee8f


This forum uses Lukasz Tkacz MyBB addons.