Linux Kodi 15 - some mkv with mp3 audio -> no audio - Printable Version +- Kodi Community Forum (https://forum.kodi.tv) +-- Forum: Support (https://forum.kodi.tv/forumdisplay.php?fid=33) +--- Forum: General Support (https://forum.kodi.tv/forumdisplay.php?fid=111) +---- Forum: Linux (https://forum.kodi.tv/forumdisplay.php?fid=52) +---- Thread: Linux Kodi 15 - some mkv with mp3 audio -> no audio (/showthread.php?tid=234646) |
Kodi 15 - some mkv with mp3 audio -> no audio - fxeon - 2015-08-08 Hi, I'm on archlinux up to date and i have problems with some mkv files that used to play OK before on previous releases of kodi/xbmc. I can play the files ok with audio on vlc but on kodi i have no sound on two different comps both under arch. Here is a link to the debug log: here I searched through various forums but couldn't get anything really related. I can post a short sample of movie that doesn't play audio if need be. Thank you for your time RE: Kodi 15 - some mkv with mp3 audio -> no audio - DaVu - 2015-08-08 do you really think anyone wants to look at over 6000 lines of a logfile ? enable debug logging, disable all epg and PVR things, reboot, reproduce your issue as fast as you can, grab the log, provide the link. If it's only with some special files, the logfile should only be logged for a few minutes (1-3 minutes after bootup). Always keep logs as short as possible RE: Kodi 15 - some mkv with mp3 audio -> no audio - fxeon - 2015-08-08 True I will edit it, sorry RE: Kodi 15 - some mkv with mp3 audio -> no audio - DaVu - 2015-08-09 Please don't edit a logfile...just do those things I explained and the log should then be short enough RE: Kodi 15 - some mkv with mp3 audio -> no audio - fxeon - 2015-08-09 There you go: -Long version (cleaned from pvr plugins ) -short one I forgot to add that all those videos i can't read were transcoded using handbrake, they used to read fine before on kodi and they still do on vlc. and btw the log is spewing error and it's still 6k lines RE: Kodi 15 - some mkv with mp3 audio -> no audio - fritsch - 2015-08-09 As one can never trust arch linux (mixture of untested latest and greatest combined with the latest and greatest gcc compiler (which fucked up ffmpeg more than once)). Please try OpenELEC beta3 from an usb stick and see if the problem with this file persists. If it is the case - provide us a sample. RE: Kodi 15 - some mkv with mp3 audio -> no audio - fritsch - 2015-08-09 Quote:13:05:02 T:139790221559552 INFO: ffmpeg[7F23727FC700]: Stream #0:1(fre), 5, 1/1000: Audio: mp3, 48000 Hz, mono, s16p, 128 kb/s (default) Btw. this seems certainly wrong. Are you sure - this should be only 1 channel Audio? Can you post the output of ffprobe with that sample? RE: Kodi 15 - some mkv with mp3 audio -> no audio - fxeon - 2015-08-09 (2015-08-09, 08:20)fritsch Wrote:There you go, downloading openelec right nowQuote:13:05:02 T:139790221559552 INFO: ffmpeg[7F23727FC700]: Stream #0:1(fre), 5, 1/1000: Audio: mp3, 48000 Hz, mono, s16p, 128 kb/s (default) Code: ffprobe S02E01.mkv RE: Kodi 15 - some mkv with mp3 audio -> no audio - fxeon - 2015-08-09 (2015-08-09, 08:09)fritsch Wrote: As one can never trust arch linux (mixture of untested latest and greatest combined with the latest and greatest gcc compiler (which fucked up ffmpeg more than once)). Please try OpenELEC beta3 from an usb stick and see if the problem with this file persists. If it is the case - provide us a sample. Same problem with openelec : Openelec log Here's a link to a sample: 1 min sample Thanx for your time. RE: Kodi 15 - some mkv with mp3 audio -> no audio - fxeon - 2015-08-09 Oh wait ! I just realised that after cutting it, it reads fine in openelec, seems that it's more a problem with handbrake rather than kodi, wrong mkv encapsulation? i'll keep investigating... it is still weird that vlc can read it and not kodi, i'll prepare a 30 secs sample with handbrake to test it. RE: Kodi 15 - some mkv with mp3 audio -> no audio - fxeon - 2015-08-09 here's a 30 sec sample freshly made with handbrake, as i suspected it reads fine in vlc but no sound in openelec... seems like handbrake has problem with mp3 encapsulation in mkv... 30 sec hanbrake sample RE: Kodi 15 - some mkv with mp3 audio -> no audio - fritsch - 2015-08-09 I rather think it's this "one channel" mono mp3? Any reason you do it mono? RE: Kodi 15 - some mkv with mp3 audio -> no audio - fxeon - 2015-08-09 Source was mono I guess (I honestly can't remember as i did it several years ago)...but i have same problem with other files which have 2 channel stereo mp3 track (I can provide an other stereo sample) RE: Kodi 15 - some mkv with mp3 audio -> no audio - fritsch - 2015-08-09 Mind filing the bug with handbrake? Kodi should not have to carry workarounds for broken encoder software. RE: Kodi 15 - some mkv with mp3 audio -> no audio - fxeon - 2015-08-09 indeed ! Thanks for your help and keep up the great work. I was suspecting kodi to be responsible for that because it used to work pre-Isengaard but I guess it's just that it became more rule adherent. |