+- Kodi Community Forum (https://forum.kodi.tv)
+-- Forum: Support (https://forum.kodi.tv/forumdisplay.php?fid=33)
+--- Forum: General Support (https://forum.kodi.tv/forumdisplay.php?fid=111)
+---- Forum: Android (https://forum.kodi.tv/forumdisplay.php?fid=164)
+---- Thread: Sync Playback to Display doesn't do 23.976 to 24 at 60hz anymore (Leia RC) (/showthread.php?tid=339822)
RE: Sync Playback to Display doesn't do 23.976 to 24 at 60hz anymore (Leia RC) - wedok - 2019-10-19
Dear Kodi devlopers,
will this huge bug be fixed in Kodi 18.5?
Or is Kodi Lea now back to alpha stage?
RE: Sync Playback to Display doesn't do 23.976 to 24 at 60hz anymore (Leia RC) - fritsch - 2019-10-19
No and nobody is working on it.
RE: Sync Playback to Display doesn't do 23.976 to 24 at 60hz anymore (Leia RC) - wedok - 2020-03-31
Does it work now?
Why can c64 play video and audio faster and slower while 2020 Hardware with Kodi/Libreelec isn't able to do it?
RE: Sync Playback to Display doesn't do 23.976 to 24 at 60hz anymore (Leia RC) - fritsch - 2020-03-31
(2020-03-31, 02:45)wedok Wrote: Does it work now?
Why can c64 play video and audio faster and slower while 2020 Hardware with Kodi/Libreelec isn't able to do it?
Because there are so many demanding leechers out there and no one investing their freetime to fix low hanging fruit bugs. Second reason is, that average IQ has fallen a lot in the last years, you can easily see that when people generalize a local problem to make it a global issue. Rough times, not sure they will change.
RE: Sync Playback to Display doesn't do 23.976 to 24 at 60hz anymore (Leia RC) - wedok - 2020-04-11
How many time do we have to wait that a simple function (playback video & audio slower/faster) is done?
I mean, is it complicated vst instruments virtual tb-303 audio code?
So, kodi devs. please do something, that also europeans get the best quality out of kodi.
RE: Sync Playback to Display doesn't do 23.976 to 24 at 60hz anymore (Leia RC) - fritsch - 2020-04-11
Who is "we" besides you?
RE: Sync Playback to Display doesn't do 23.976 to 24 at 60hz anymore (Leia RC) - fritsch - 2020-04-11
As you say it's so simple:
https://github.com/xbmc/xbmc/blob/master/xbmc/cores/VideoPlayer/DVDClock.cpp#L246
start here. If you have questions, just ask - but low hanging fruits, as you think it is, is best solved by new contributors. Therefore go ahead.
RE: Sync Playback to Display doesn't do 23.976 to 24 at 60hz anymore (Leia RC) - wedok - 2020-06-03
Kodi 18.7, does "Sync Playback to Display" work now?
RE: Sync Playback to Display doesn't do 23.976 to 24 at 60hz anymore (Leia RC) - wedok - 2020-08-16
Kodi 18.8, does "Sync Playback to Display" work now?
RE: Sync Playback to Display doesn't do 23.976 to 24 at 60hz anymore (Leia RC) - wedok - 2020-09-27
Will Kodi 19 finally have a working "Sync Playback to Display" again?
In Kodi 18.8 it still doesnt work
RE: Sync Playback to Display doesn't do 23.976 to 24 at 60hz anymore (Leia RC) - fritsch - 2020-09-27
It is still broken.
RE: Sync Playback to Display doesn't do 23.976 to 24 at 60hz anymore (Leia RC) - fritsch - 2020-09-27
Now without kidding:
Quote:2020-09-27 17:25:44.619 T:11976 NOTICE: Creating audio stream (codec id: 86020, channels: 6, sample rate: 48000, no pass-through)
2020-09-27 17:25:44.620 T:11976 DEBUG: CVideoPlayerAudio:: synctype set to 1: resample
2020-09-27 17:25:44.670 T:11975 DEBUG: CRenderManager::Configure - change configuration. 1920x816. display: 1920x816. framerate: 23.98.
2020-09-27 17:25:44.684 T:11462 DEBUG: DeleteRenderer - deleting renderer
2020-09-27 17:25:44.684 T:11462 DEBUG: LinuxRendererGLES: Cleaning up GLES resources
2020-09-27 17:25:44.698 T:11462 NOTICE: Instancing CRendererMediaCodecSurface
2020-09-27 17:25:44.699 T:11462 NOTICE: CRendererMediaCodecSurface::Configure
2020-09-27 17:25:44.699 T:11462 DEBUG: CRenderManager::Configure - 4
2020-09-27 17:25:44.699 T:11975 DEBUG: CVideoReferenceClock: Clock speed 100.10 %
Just tried on Android. Works perfectly fine. 60 hz Display and 23.98 (exactly 23.976) fps input, it's speed up to 24.0 and played at 60 hz.
So what exactly is your problem?
RE: Sync Playback to Display doesn't do 23.976 to 24 at 60hz anymore (Leia RC) - Sneeka - 2020-09-28
(2020-09-27, 17:29)fritsch Wrote: Just tried on Android. Works perfectly fine. 60 hz Display and 23.98 (exactly 23.976) fps input, it's speed up to 24.0 and played at 60 hz.I have a feeling it's gone a little off the original topic, but I imagine it's the same issue I have.
So what exactly is your problem?
Looks like the speedup from 23.976 to 24.000 is resolved, but the 23.976 to 25.000 speedup (~104.271%) that used to be possible (to sync to 50hz displays) no longer is.
If you don't have a 120hz display you have to settle for 24fps @ 60hz with pulldown.
I'm guessing most people are ok with this, but I can't stand pulldown judder, which was why the speedup to sync with the display's 50hz mode was a godsend.
Seems like Krypton v17.6 was the last version that did this. Still happy enough using it, but hopefully someone will restore this option in the latest builds. Either that or I should probably just get a 120hz display 🤔
RE: Sync Playback to Display doesn't do 23.976 to 24 at 60hz anymore (Leia RC) - fritsch - 2020-09-28
25p I fixed some days ago. But it's not yet merged and will be v19 only.
Let me know what kind of test build you need.
RE: Sync Playback to Display doesn't do 23.976 to 24 at 60hz anymore (Leia RC) - Sneeka - 2020-09-28
(2020-09-28, 16:20)fritsch Wrote: 25p I fixed some days ago. But it's not yet merged and will be v19 only.
Let me know what kind of test build you need.
Sweet, thanks. Although I just realised I'm in the Android section
..I assume the same fix will be in the Windows release too? If so, then a Windows build if possible.