Posts: 14,213
Joined: Nov 2009
Reputation:
707
Klojum
Lost connection
Posts: 14,213
Synology is perhaps not at the top of hardware innovations in NASses, but their firmware/software and its support is second to none AFAICT. They basically support a NAS for 5 years, and sometimes beyond that when it involves major security fixes. Any current Syno or QNap NAS should be more than capable of serving files to Kodi.
Posts: 1,074
Joined: Jun 2012
Reputation:
16
Cool. I like a few QNAP as well, but reviews seem a bit worse, but better specs.
I just need to get away from WD devices for a bit.
I'd like one that could somehow be accessible via a USB as well...but that defeats the purpose of the NAS, I suppose.
Video seems more stable if I'm USB plugged rather than through the router.
Hmm...
Back to comparing. Thanks!
Posts: 1,074
Joined: Jun 2012
Reputation:
16
Interesting. By USB, I meant an External HD via USB 3.0 seems to give smooth playback. Using a MyCloud via ether net, it sometimes stutters or freezes Kodi. I never use wifi for the same reason.
However, the MyCloud no longer connects... So...
It may have not been the best source to begin with.
I literally play video on 1x Chromebox and backup my cell phone pictures. I only have a few dozen 1080p, and the rest are 720p or smaller. No 4k.
Synology is my current pick. I didn't realize the 218 was ARM. The plus puts me at $300. Trying to get around $200. I like a few QNAP, but I may just suck it up and go with what works best.
Posts: 14,213
Joined: Nov 2009
Reputation:
707
Klojum
Lost connection
Posts: 14,213
The 'simple' ARM-based Synology NAS should also be more than capable of pushing out videos via ethernet to whatever network device you have. I'm not sure if you even need the more grunty plus version of the 218 NAS, unless you have "big plans" for the future. Simple backups and video storage is not a complex thing. And also, a NAS is not a backup: it's just another drive. Keep more than one backup around of your important files.
Posts: 1,074
Joined: Jun 2012
Reputation:
16
2019-01-07, 04:20
(This post was last modified: 2019-01-07, 04:53 by McButton.)
I actually went with a Synology 218. I plugged my bare MyCloud HD into it to check the scan and found like 130 bad sectors. So, definitely jacked.
I was able to plug it into my laptop via USB and a Linux program to read the partitions. All the data is available.
I can also NOW get it to run via Ethernet like normal. It just started working again.
That said, I want all the data on my Synology. What would be the best way to make that happen? If I just drop and drag over the network, it's like 1MB/sec.
If I plug into the NAS via USB it can't be read, because of the partitions.
If I leave the MyCloud on the network, I can mount it as a remote folder and drag the files where I want. This seems to take a long time just to transfer 40MB. Likely the same as just dragging via my laptop, but I won't need the laptop on since it was a network command.
That can't be it...can it? I've looked online for hours and found barely any info. It seems like a pretty common thing.
Posts: 1,074
Joined: Jun 2012
Reputation:
16
UPDATE: For anyone in the same situation...
I mounted the shares from the old NAS and just copied or cut/paste in the Synology DSM site.
It goes something like 80MB/sec now.
Tricky.
Posts: 1,074
Joined: Jun 2012
Reputation:
16
I got it all sorted. Using the Synology NAS is insane. I never realized how much of a trash box the MyCloud was.
I did the 218 rather than the 218+. Saved $50, and I didn't need the extra power. The 218play only had 1GB ram vs 2, so that seemed worth the $20 upgrade.
It's running great now.
* MyCloud always had connection issues and the site was always down. This is always running fine.
* The MyCloud always needed me to transfer files with the PC to some degree or it would just error off. The Synology just runs the task through the network, and I come back to it being done. It also has a check to make sure none of the files are jacked. Syno took 2 days to transfer 6TB with 2 button clicks. The MyCloud took me several horrible weeks of messing to put 4TB into it last time.
Got a 20TB NAS for under $600.
Thanks for all the assistance!