I tried several blurays with debug and i have my first results. I tried all discs with the original copy and anydvd hd with 3 different softwares to have the results. Kodi, dslibbluray and Total Media theater. I have 5 observations:
1) Almost everytime main menu shows up before it should. Usually in blurays there is a video to play before the menu and when it ended it starts a 2nd video behind the menu with the menu. In kodi the menu always appear before the end of the first and not when it ends and starts the 2nd. I tried with dslibbluray and it doesn't happen so is kodi related
2) I have 3 blurays with truehd and all have slowed-down playback and audio problems. When i change the audio track everything returns normal. This only happens with menu loaded and not loading directly the playlist. Also in this case dslibbluray doesn't have the problem so probably kodi problem.
3) Usually next chapter and previous chapter are arrow up and arrow down. With blurays it seems they never work, also triggering from the dvdplayer bar doesn't work.
4) Bluray have sometimes localized menus. Is this something it's not implemented in libbluray, something that libbluray has and kodi doesn't or that kodi has and i failed to use?
5) DSLibbluray only plays bd menu. Nothing else. Has only 4 functions: Next chapter, previous chapter, top menu, popup menu (working only in hdmv) but is smoother and more "premium" than actual kodi so is a good comparison even if it uses libbluray 0.2 right now.
Here's my lists (all italian versions except some):
Working:
V for vendetta (BD-J)
the dark knight (BD-J)
batman begins (BD-J)
the dark knight rises (BD-J)
young frankenstein (BD-J)
argo (BD-J)
Spider-man (BD-J)
Man in black 2 (BD-J)
Moulin Rouge (BD-J)
Avatar ext coll edition (BD-J)
Avatar ext coll edition extra 1 (BD-J)
veronica mars - the movie (eng) (HDMV)
man of steel (HDMV)
2001 space odissey (HDMV)
Partially working:
the dark knight extras (BD-J) - no audio, subtitle selection doesn't work. Works perfectly in dslibbluray -
Log
Man in black (BD-J) - menu works well but when i play the bd it doesn't. It's all noise and crackle and video play jerky because of truehd (works in dslibbluray and with other audio tracks) -
Log
The Green Mile (HDMV) - No main menu so it starts to play directly but it's all noise and crackle and video play jerky because of truehd (works in dslibbluray and with other audio tracks) -
Log
Blade Runner (HDMV) - No main menu so it starts to play directly but it's all noise and crackle and video play jerky because of truehd (works in dslibbluray and with other audio tracks) -
Log
the dark knight rises extra (HDMV) - no audio, subtitle selection doesn't work. Works perfectly in dslibbluray -
Log
the prestige (HDMV) - extras play all works, play single track doesn't load video and audio, only subs -
Log
Not working:
star trek (BD-J) - black screen with white hover in the menu no text and can't move -
Log
star trek extras (BD-J) - black screen with white hover in the menu no text and can't move -
Log
Spider-man 2 (BD-J) - keeps spinning and doesn't load -
Log
Spider-man 3 (BD-J) - keeps spinning and doesn't load -
Log
Man in black 3 (BD-J) - black screen and hangs on menu load (after sony video logo) -
Log
Shindler's list (BD-J) - keeps spinning and doesn't load -
Log
Avatar ext coll edition extra 2 (BD-J) - keeps spinning and doesn't load -
Log