Posts: 3,735
Joined: Dec 2010
Reputation:
53
negge
yo guysv7may bd latr tomorroe
Posts: 3,735
2013-09-26, 15:51
(This post was last modified: 2013-09-26, 15:52 by negge.)
My observations are the following:
On a fairly powerful HTPC (Phenom II x3 processor, 8 GB RAM) using tvheadend and a Terratec Cinergy C PCI tuner, channel changes take roughly 2,2 seconds (2,7 for scrambled ones, slightly longer for HD). A friend of mine has the same setup except the tuner is an old FireDTV C/CI, there channel changes take noticably longer (haven't measured it though). I have never tried other backends so I can't provide any subjective comments there.
I may add that the 2,2 seconds mentioned earlier is the time until the video starts playing - the initial still frame appears after just over a second.
Posts: 664
Joined: Nov 2008
Reputation:
5
Its been mentioned before that there is an issue with XBMC code (especially when switching HD <> SD IIRC) - FernetMenta and Margro did some work on speeding things up if I recall, and managed to get the times down to a second or two, but I don't think the code has made it into the main XBMC builds yet.
Posts: 40
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation:
0
An interesting thread.
I've long thought although there has been a lot of excellent work done to bring PVR support to XBMC (I take my hat off the the guys doing this), the approach is wrong. Its just a little too late to change it though.
My approach would have been to only use the back end software (Mediaportal, TVHeadend etc..) to play the channels. I would have programmed a lot more of the functionality into XBMC itself, such as recordings. If XBMC handled the timers itself, it wouldn't matter what backend you used. XBMC would simply at a given time tell the backend to play/record a channel.
In my view using this approach... programming it initially would have taken a lot more time and effort but ongoing would be a lot less hassle. More features would be able to be added in the long run as they are all handled internally and the user experience in my humble view would be better.
I use XBMC every day. At the moment its not family friendly which is actually good for me as I get to choose what we watch. My current set up is Openelec on a pc under the TV, a Rpi in the bedroom, XBMC on my android phone, a main server in another room housing TVHeadend, and a couple of tuners and all the hard disks. I do use the TVHeadend web interface to record stuff as its much easier for me. I also use the TVHeadend Android app which works fine. But these are not family friendly. TVHeadend for instance crashes at least 4 times a week. I need to log in using SSH and restart the service. How many people want to do that?
We are geeks. We use XBMC because of that fact I believe. XBMC has fantastic functionality and its great having PVR support, But in order to make other people use it, it needs to become easier to use. Everything should be able to be done on the screen just like a normal Sat box can. A couple of clicks done. We are some way off from that though.
-----------------------------------
Front End: Asrock ION 3D running OpenElec - Backend: Dedicated server Running Ubuntu with TBS 6981 DVB-S2 USB
Posts: 19,982
Joined: May 2009
Reputation:
451
nickr
Retired Team-Kodi Member
Posts: 19,982
Then the front end would need to be on when the recording is due to start and finish, and many frontends could be telling a single backend to do conflictting things, bad design sorry.
If I have helped you or increased your knowledge, click the 'thumbs up' button to give thanks :) (People with less than 20 posts won't see the "thumbs up" button.)
Posts: 11
Joined: Sep 2013
Reputation:
0
banhuk
Junior Member
Posts: 11
I Just found this thread..
I love having live TV and live tv recording (including series) ability on my front end.
Up until a few weeks ago, I had a Synology backend running DVBlink tv server and Plex server.
I had an NUC running XBMC (Openelec) as frontend.
I have 2 Dual tuner Hdhomerun network tuners.
To get live scheduling from XBMC frontend, I did 4 fairly simple steps..
1. Installed DVBlink channel plugin for Plex server.
2. Installed PleXbmc addon for XBMC.
3. Installed DVBlink client for XBMC.
3. Installed Amber skin for XBMC - this linked it all together (this skin supports PleXbmc fully - quite nice if you haven't tried it before).
In everyday use, the live tv channel changes were 2 seconds.
The wife and I used live TV in XBMC for watching tv and single episode recording (via tv guide).
To record series, we simply went to the main menu and selected the DVBlink Plex channel.
Unfortunately I uninstalled everything the other day to try out the latest synology DSM (operating system) and the new DVBlink 5 that just came out and I found out that DVBlink no longer supports or develops the Plex channel. Which was a pity, because the latest Plex with the DVBlink channel installed was so slick, I was ready to ditch XBMC altogether. So frustrating. I guess I could try and find and old copy on the net somewhere....
I see this thread has been quiet for a few months now. Can anyone else share there setup with a record series feature from their XBMC front end??
I installed mediaportal backend on a spare windows server i had and client on my windows NUC yesterday and had a play. It was ok, but not as fast and slick as XBMC. Also, it is was not as user friendly for the wife for live tv (although it's reasonable and I am interested to see what the future holds). The addons were better than I expected, but again not as vast and as slick as XBMC.
Oh well back to the drawing board...
Hooroo :-)
banhuk
Posts: 11
Joined: Sep 2013
Reputation:
0
banhuk
Junior Member
Posts: 11
Awesome.. Thanks simbo...
I was just reading about WMC backend fro XBMC...
So what skins support in that you know of??
Will give it a go...
Posts: 37
Joined: Dec 2009
Reputation:
0
It amazes me in this day and age we have to resort to Media Center still. I have HD Homerun tuners and think it would be great if I didnt need another product to grab EPG and record (in the US, we get no love) shows. The info is very easy to find (IMDB, tvrage, zap, etc) seems like it would be simple (and please dont get me started w xml programs).
Posts: 19,982
Joined: May 2009
Reputation:
451
nickr
Retired Team-Kodi Member
Posts: 19,982
Do you mean windows media centre? I certainly don't use it.
There is a lot to what you suggest - conflicts, repeat showings, priorities, scheduling.
If I have helped you or increased your knowledge, click the 'thumbs up' button to give thanks :) (People with less than 20 posts won't see the "thumbs up" button.)