2017-03-18, 21:17
Thanks for the testing feedback @Gracus.
Discussing with @FernetMenta on Git he is still pretty sure that having an avoid clipping setting is a silly thing. Why reduce gain across the entire song to avoid clipping when the AE can cleverly protect against clipping on just those places that need it?
I am suggesting that as it produces a different sound (when clipping would happen) then the option for reduced gain approach is valid. But I don't use this, and no one here has complained about clipping protection behaviour.
The replaygain not working unless peak = 1.0 is a bug that will be fixed, just the clipping protection apporach that is being debated.
Discussing with @FernetMenta on Git he is still pretty sure that having an avoid clipping setting is a silly thing. Why reduce gain across the entire song to avoid clipping when the AE can cleverly protect against clipping on just those places that need it?
I am suggesting that as it produces a different sound (when clipping would happen) then the option for reduced gain approach is valid. But I don't use this, and no one here has complained about clipping protection behaviour.
The replaygain not working unless peak = 1.0 is a bug that will be fixed, just the clipping protection apporach that is being debated.
