2009-08-06, 12:12
althekiller Wrote:Oh dear...where to start. I'm sure your intentions were pure and all, but I simply can't condone the use of a tool such as this. The concept is sound, assuming everything goes as planned, but what if an error occurs? There's no useful output, no error checking at all, it's all extremely naive. How are we supposed to offer support to users who have no idea what they've done? Linux isn't Windows, the type of person who will find this script useful doesn't know that. How can they help us help them? If they had installed manually, not only would they know at what stage an error occurred, but they would have learned from all of the steps leading up to it. Users who aren't willing to learn a little bit to get what they want, aren't ready for Linux either.
So if you're ready to handle every support questions from every user who installs with this script, regardless of whether it applies directly to the script or not, great, we'll move the posts here. Otherwise, I'm going to have to discourage all users from installing with this method.
I'm sorry I have to be so discouraging on the matter. Hopefully you can find some other way to contribute you skills to the community.
Allthekiller, I respectfully think you have not thought this thoroughly. What cyberpark is giving us here is pure open source!!! how can you condemn that? he gives the .sh file (both listed here and as a link) that is the source at the same time as the executable, and explains how it works and why it does what it does (and most if not all is taken from this forum). In the forum itself usually people recommends adding random binary repositories and keys and blindly upgrading from them! that is I think the right thing to do, but at the same time IMHO is much more questionable than giving people a fully commented .sh script to run!
Regarding errors and support, there are logs and console output, and people can ask here, and of course everything people do freely (free as in beer and as in speech) is their own responsibility. We will try simply to help them.