2019-09-04, 21:56
(2019-09-04, 21:48)HeresJohnny Wrote:(2019-08-28, 22:47)black_eagle Wrote: If you don't add the tag then Kodi will create boxsets whereI should think the third criterium needs to read that album IS in fact marked as compilation. If "Album + Compilation" is missing on MB it would be easy to amend there.
- all discs have titles &
- there are 3 or more discs &
- the album isn't marked as a compilation in the tags
NO... I have a large number of box sets that are NOT compilations.
Why do you keep saying that all box sets are compilations? They arent!
This IS a box set, it is NOT a compilation
https://musicbrainz.org/release/a15fd67a...25c40b7bd7
This IS a box set, it is NOT a compilation
https://musicbrainz.org/release/23854e73...7bffe793f4
This IS a box set, it is NOT a compilation
https://musicbrainz.org/release/1877489f...5f316e7c12
I have maybe 40 box sets, and only very few are actually true "compilations" (I consider compilations either greatest hits packages, of anthologies covering decades etc). Theres a handful more like "more blood more tracks" that MB considers compilations (but I would think differently)
What should be noted from MB guidelines:
The MusicBrainz project does not generally consider the following to be compilations:
a reissue of an album, even if it includes bonus tracks.
a tribute release containing covers of music by another artist.
a classical release containing new recordings of works by a classical artist.
So for instance, the Above re-releases of The White Album, Rumours, Ram DO NOT qualify as compilations under MB guidelines.
The vast majority of my box sets are super deluxe or deluxe re-releases of albums./
another example
https://musicbrainz.org/release/28b119b5...a7bc4fad52
Box set reissue of the Joshua tree with 3 discs of bonus material. Not a compilation.