[artrafael]

Upload the debug log (wiki) file to www.xbmclogs.com and post the URL link to the uploaded file here with your reply. This allows viewing of the file on-line without having to download it plus various elements will be highlighted automatically to improve readability.

[benzodeaze]

karoshi99 & benzodeaze could you please create the error again and post your log files? I can't say that it will help get some developer attention but at least they won't be able to say we didn't give them all of the info we have.

Thanks.

here's my log file after trying to play AUDIO CD a couple of time.
http://www.xbmclogs.com/show.php?id=8169
I'm on Windows Home Basic x86, Asus EEEbox PC EB1501P.
Thanks in advance for support on this problem.

[karoshi99]

Upload the debug log (wiki) file to www.xbmclogs.com and post the URL link to the uploaded file here with your reply. This allows viewing of the file on-line without having to download it plus various elements will be highlighted automatically to improve readability.

Here we go: http://www.xbmclogs.com/show.php?id=8175

[WiSo]

Could any of you with problems using a usb drive please test this: http://mirrors.xbmc.org/build-deps/win32...792-dx.exe
It's today's nightly but the third party library libcdio was replaced by windows methods to read the audio cd.

[rcrh]

Could any of you with problems using a usb drive please test this: http://mirrors.xbmc.org/build-deps/win32...792-dx.exe
It's today's nightly but the third party library libcdio was replaced by windows methods to read the audio cd.

Before I bite on this can I install this without touching my existing implementation? I guess I could log in as a second user and install just for that user. Would that work?

Thanks for looking at this.

[WiSo]

Yeah that would work or start xbmc with -p. It'll then store all userdata inside the installation folder.

[WiSo]

Anyone else? Would like to know if this is the right direction, clean it up and bring it in the next merge window. Otherwise it won't go into the next release.

[rcrh]

Could any of you with problems using a usb drive please test this: http://mirrors.xbmc.org/build-deps/win32...792-dx.exe
It's today's nightly but the third party library libcdio was replaced by windows methods to read the audio cd.

no joy.
with debug off nothing was written to the log. with debug on I got this

http://xbmclogs.com/show.php?id=9346

please let me know if there's anything else i can try.

[WiSo]

then I'm out off ideas. I'm using windows standard ioctls and it works fine on my laptop and desktop. I don't have an usb drive to test but wonder why this shouldn't work. we can't use simple mci commands here as we need the raw input.
Btw you should choose a different audio device. Try directsound.

[mysticpete]

No change to this issue in Frodo 12 either, think you can forget the playing and ripping cd's bit in XBMC for the long term.

[rcrh]

Wow, that's really is disappointing.

[bearh]

Not really.

Today I resolved the issue on the GNU/Linux x86 system and partly on RPi. There is a bug probably in libcdio but a patch to xbmc is enough to play and rip CD audio from USB drive. I will send the patch to the xbmc track and hopefully it will be included to xbmc sources.

Edit: Here is pull request: https://github.com/xbmc/xbmc/pull/2570

[rcrh]

Wow, that really is exciting!

(Wow, I'm very volitile).

[mysticpete]

Not really.

Today I resolved the issue on the GNU/Linux x86 system and partly on RPi. There is a bug probably in libcdio but a patch to xbmc is enough to play and rip CD audio from USB drive. I will send the patch to the xbmc track and hopefully it will be included to xbmc sources.

Edit: Here is pull request: https://github.com/xbmc/xbmc/pull/2570

Thanks for taking this up and having a look
it's appreciated by those that wish to play CD's and Rrrrrrip!

[WiSo]

So hopefully this will work on windows too. It's merged and should be available in tomorrows nightly.