Posts: 47
Joined: Jul 2010
Reputation:
0
Xeno43
Junior Member
Posts: 47
Yes the Raspberry Pi will do everything you want. I recommend the most recent version of openelec. You'll need to buy like $10 of accessories as well as the pi, not really that big a deal.
Posts: 40
Joined: May 2013
Reputation:
1
I liked the RAPi, until i wanted to watch hugh fullHD files. But over all it is smooth and working.
Beside the hardware you also need to buy the codec, otherwise you will have a problem watching SD.
Posts: 701
Joined: May 2010
Reputation:
26
If you want fast and snappy dont get a PI. Its a fun toy but the celeron nuc's are a pretty good deal and are a few hundred times faster. To get a PI to perform well it needs overclocking, usb install, and codecs. just spend around ~200$ and get something that will work well for years to come.
Posts: 47
Joined: Jul 2010
Reputation:
0
Xeno43
Junior Member
Posts: 47
I really hate the FUD surround the Raspbery Pi on this forum.
Between me and my immediate family, we own over 10 Raspberry Pi's. Each one is capable of running 1080P H264 encoded files (which is all that is released today, and even if you've been around for a while only 3 of my 600 movies weren't H264). Each one runs the User Interface smoothly, though on fanart mode the fanart can take a second to load.
The Raspberry Pi is automatically overclocked in OpenElec, and if you wish to overclock it more there is literally a text file where you increase the number next to the word overclock. However I have never needed to do this.
And you do not need any codecs, that's just straight up wrong. It can play SD video just fine by using the CPU to decode.
Why the guy above me complains about something he named USB install is beyond me. The OS lives on an SD card, you don't install over USB. And why he says spending an hour to fix up a Raspberry pi which will cost $50 including accessories is not worth it and you should spend $200 on a full system just sounds stupid, to be honest.
Any other questions or FUD just ask.
Posts: 701
Joined: May 2010
Reputation:
26
2014-01-27, 02:05
(This post was last modified: 2014-01-27, 02:07 by calev.)
Most raspberry Pis have sc card corruption when over-clocked to 1gz. Hence the USB install. The USB install also makes loading fan-arts much quicker becouse the sd card reads much slower. I have plenty of bluray rips that are vc1(planet earth), and mpeg 2(terminator 2) that my pi can't play without codecs. My Pi cost more like 85$ after case, power supply, hdmi, sd card, shipping. you can get a celeron up and running with a ir receiver for around 200 now. And it runs all the skins and all the add-ons painlessly. I don’t get why people get so offended when stating an obvious fact like a 700mhz arm processor is noticeably and sometimes painfully slower than any x86 alternative released in the last 5 years. To me that just sounds stupid, to be honest.
Posts: 276
Joined: Jan 2013
Reputation:
0
Between me and my immediate family, we sub - par ver 10 Raspberry Pi's. Each one is capable ofNUunning 1080P H264 encoded files (which is all that is released today, and even if you've been around for a while only 3 of my 600 movies weren't H264). Each one runs the User Interface smoothly, though on fanart mode the fanart can take a second to load.
The Raspberry Pi is automatically overclocked in OpenElec, and if you wish to overclock it more there is literally a text file where you increase the number next to the word overclock. However I have
Why the guy above me complains about something he named USB install is beyond me. The OS lives on an SD card, you don't install over USB. And why he says spending an hour to fix up a Raspberry pi which will cost $50 including accessories is not worth it and you should spend $200 on a full system just sounds stupid, to be honest.
Any other questions or FUD just ask.
[/quote]
USB install is the smoothiest, snappyest, and onlyest way to go with a Raspberry Pi if you ask me. And even booting from USB it is still a sub-par performer in the grand scheme of things. NUC or even Ouya might be worth looking into for you.
Posts: 56
Joined: Jun 2012
Reputation:
0
I have a RPi and works great if setup the right way. There are also other contenders like the cubox-i. There has been some progress in openelec development for cubox in the past week. So if i were you i would an eye out for that too.
HTPC :: OpenELEC VM UnRAiD
NAS :: UnRAID 6 • Data 5x2 TB • Parity 2TB • Docker • VM
Panasonic 46" LED • Yamaha YHT-2910 HT
Posts: 471
Joined: Dec 2011
Reputation:
10
2014-01-27, 15:13
(This post was last modified: 2014-01-27, 15:14 by joelbaby.)
I would buy a Cubox-i instead of a raspberry pi.
For a start there is a $45 model, which is 5x faster than a Pi, and includes a box and IR receiver (which the Pi does not).
There is a $100 model which is better for xbmc.
It is much smaller than a Pi too.
The person who wrote Raspbmc (raspberry pi xbmc) is rewriting raspbmc for the cubox-i.
Also, Openelec, Geexbox, and Yocto XBMC variants are also available (all builds are early versions).
Posts: 497
Joined: Jul 2011
Reputation:
5
I love the raspi. For anyone with a spare smartphone charger and an SD card and thumb drive laying around, it really is about $45. Case is optional. The other (really big) advantage to buying a raspi over just about any other cheap unit, is that it's standardized and one of the most popular XBMC platforms with thousands of people using it. You won't get the same level of support with any other XBMC machine IMO.
Yeah, you can buy a higher performing NUC for $200. Or why not buy a custom built i7-based HTPC for $500 while you're at it? If you can afford these, then go for it and yes they'll probably be faster. But if you're looking the best value at a low price point then it's really hard to beat the raspi.
And if you have an ounce of "tinkering" interest then you'll probably become addicted to the raspi. I have two raspi's for XBMC, another one powering a sous vide machine, and yet another one permanently configured as a timelapse camera for the Longfellow Bridge here in Boston. A "smart wifi thermostat" project is next. They're wonderful devices.
Posts: 56
Joined: Jan 2014
Reputation:
0
I would not use the pi since the sports streams you mention will often send you crashing to the menu due to dead links. Menu on pi is super slow. I used one in my bedroom for months. It was so slow i never updated my library and used the file system. At that point, what is the point of xbmc? Ouya is faster and around the same price once you factor in all the hardware needed for an optimal pi experience. I suggest an ouya for cheap little boxes. The $200 level gets you to the nuc options.
Posts: 359
Joined: May 2009
Reputation:
8
2014-01-28, 04:57
(This post was last modified: 2014-01-28, 04:58 by katsup.)
I have two pis and they work fine for my needs (bedroom & 2nd TV). My main TV has a Shuttle mini pc.
I had issues with menu speed when I first set it up. I installed it on a USB 3.0 flash drive, but it somehow got corrupt and I had to reinstall it. I decided to install the OS on a SanDisk Extreme Pro (95MB/s) and I have no speed issues with the menu anymore.
As far as limitations, there have been some video where it has difficulty playing. Most of which were bluray isos that I just wanted to see if the pi could handle it. An annoying thing is that the CEC buttons for my Panasonic TV remote changed so now the PLAY, STOP, RWD, etc... no longer work. The menu and the buttons I setup manually still work though. I haven't really investigated why they stopped working yet as it is only slightly annoying.
Posts: 56
Joined: Jan 2014
Reputation:
0
2014-01-28, 04:59
(This post was last modified: 2014-01-28, 05:04 by magister.)
I agree the addons are often the problem. But they crash to the menu and that blasted menu was so slow. I am also glad to hear the pi is faster. I am skeptical but I may check it out again. I still have the pi. Ouya is working out for me right now.
What os are you using for pi? Raspbmc or open elec?
My experience. I have used pi, pivos, 5 year old computer, and ouya. Ouya has been best. Pi was slow. Pivos a little faster, but still slow. Ouya just right. This is the first I am hearing of pi being smooth in the menues.