2012-05-16, 21:11
Sigh... also...
First, thanks again for your patiente wich is put to hardship. I can fell the vibes from here
.
I know my english is bad, and i wasn't probably clear enough, so i'll try to explain again better :
==========================================================================
Issue N°1
The facts :
A : HDMI audio VSX-921 is selected as default audio device in windows.
B : No issue with chipset VIA highjacking VSX-921 with MPC-HC and VLC.
C : No issue with chipset VIA highjacking VSX-921 with XBMC just before AE merge. I select Wasapi VSX-921 and have audio.
D : No audio from non pass-through formats since AE merged because even selected Wasapi VSX-921 the device seems not be used and seems to be highjacked by the VIA device.
OK : You've provided me a workaround to bypass the issue. Yes, fine, even more perfect, big thanks !! I don't espacialy care enabling VIA for now, that's not the point.
According the facts A+B+C, my conclusion/analysis of the situation is that the problem D is more probably (not 100% sure of course) an issue from XBMC with the new AE than something else. So, if there is an issue, it need to be fixed. This is, of course, my point of view, according my interpretation of the facts.
This, the point i insist on : Fixing this issue => Improving XBMC.
Now :
- If your analysis of this situation is different from mine, and you think the issue D is absolutely not from XBMC+new AE tells/explain/demonstrate me why.
- If you're agree with the fact that there is maybe an issue with XBMC+new AE, in that case maybe we can try to dig for knowing the cause. As i've said, i can build specific version with more log trace or anything else and run them.
Pleeeaaaase !!!! Tell me this time i've been clear enough, and you've understood what i'm trying to explain, and you'll not answer that i can enable VIA if i want..........
=====================================================================
Issue N°2
Ok for this one also.
Only one little question, with only 2 answers :
Q : In the Windows property of audio device, it reports 8 channels supported. In case of wrong EDID, is it normal ?
Answer A : No, it's odd.
Answer B : Yes, because of X and/or Y reasons. [No need to be explained].
So, for question Q, the answer is A or B ?
If it's B, closed, period !
If it's A, in that case maybe we can try to dig for knowing the cause. As i've said, i can build specific version with more log trace or anything else and run them.
=====================================================================
Issue N°3
The audio FLAC 2.0.
I've not forgotten it, but for now i'm not including it in the talk.
More complicated, i've to get it back to my standard PC, where i've all my tools, but for now i've not enough place to do the manipulations (file is 10GB), and the PC where is the file, has only XBMC on it, without any tools, because it's not it's purpose... Well, my installation make that doing this will take a little time. I'll do it, on time, and keep it on standby for now.
First, thanks again for your patiente wich is put to hardship. I can fell the vibes from here
.(2012-05-16, 20:09)DDDamian Wrote: I've told you to re-enable your VIA hw if you want.Again, you totaly miss the point !
I know my english is bad, and i wasn't probably clear enough, so i'll try to explain again better :
==========================================================================
Issue N°1
The facts :
A : HDMI audio VSX-921 is selected as default audio device in windows.
B : No issue with chipset VIA highjacking VSX-921 with MPC-HC and VLC.
C : No issue with chipset VIA highjacking VSX-921 with XBMC just before AE merge. I select Wasapi VSX-921 and have audio.
D : No audio from non pass-through formats since AE merged because even selected Wasapi VSX-921 the device seems not be used and seems to be highjacked by the VIA device.
OK : You've provided me a workaround to bypass the issue. Yes, fine, even more perfect, big thanks !! I don't espacialy care enabling VIA for now, that's not the point.
According the facts A+B+C, my conclusion/analysis of the situation is that the problem D is more probably (not 100% sure of course) an issue from XBMC with the new AE than something else. So, if there is an issue, it need to be fixed. This is, of course, my point of view, according my interpretation of the facts.
This, the point i insist on : Fixing this issue => Improving XBMC.
Now :
- If your analysis of this situation is different from mine, and you think the issue D is absolutely not from XBMC+new AE tells/explain/demonstrate me why.
- If you're agree with the fact that there is maybe an issue with XBMC+new AE, in that case maybe we can try to dig for knowing the cause. As i've said, i can build specific version with more log trace or anything else and run them.
(2012-05-16, 20:09)DDDamian Wrote: Really - what exactly would you like me to do?That was one thing.
Pleeeaaaase !!!! Tell me this time i've been clear enough, and you've understood what i'm trying to explain, and you'll not answer that i can enable VIA if i want..........
=====================================================================
Issue N°2
(2012-05-16, 20:09)DDDamian Wrote: We ping your driver - it reports 2ch - sorry, that's what it does.
Ok for this one also.
Only one little question, with only 2 answers :
Q : In the Windows property of audio device, it reports 8 channels supported. In case of wrong EDID, is it normal ?
Answer A : No, it's odd.
Answer B : Yes, because of X and/or Y reasons. [No need to be explained].
So, for question Q, the answer is A or B ?
If it's B, closed, period !
If it's A, in that case maybe we can try to dig for knowing the cause. As i've said, i can build specific version with more log trace or anything else and run them.
(2012-05-16, 20:09)DDDamian Wrote: Really - what exactly would you like me to do?That was the second thing.
=====================================================================
Issue N°3
The audio FLAC 2.0.
I've not forgotten it, but for now i'm not including it in the talk.
More complicated, i've to get it back to my standard PC, where i've all my tools, but for now i've not enough place to do the manipulations (file is 10GB), and the PC where is the file, has only XBMC on it, without any tools, because it's not it's purpose... Well, my installation make that doing this will take a little time. I'll do it, on time, and keep it on standby for now.
