[Cynwrig]

look here in Automatic Stream Selection.

I did as stated in that section. Change default to advanced and put *:ENG or ENG:*. Both don't work

Funny. Works fine for me. How do you have your subtitle files stored, or named? Are they embedded in the movie file? If separate, are they next to the movie, with the same name as the movie file? Do they have ".en.srt" at the end of the filename?

They are all embedded in the movie file. I found out something odd, this one show with (e) behind the subtitles did automatic load. It's the only show that has that and does automatically load the subtitles. Funny fact when I watch this one show first all next shows I watch got automatic subtitles.