You know, between all the small things of "that detail doesn't show up", "how do I plug my smartlist in I-don't-know-what submenu", etc, I'd like to take a moment to see the grand scheme of things.
What did Marcos do ultimately? He added functionality to Aeon. Not design, which is the main aim for all the lone gunmen designing skins around here, but functionality. The type of functionality that - if you ask me, even if I'm probably in a minority - should've been there a long time ago. How many threads are there with I want my music video/concert/documentaries/home made videos, etc on the home menu? How many threads
modding every skin to add custom menus?
So qudos to Marcos for getting it right. But what he did, raises 2 very important issues for me.
1) I won't be able to enjoy any other skin. It won't matter that they have supreme graphics; they can't leverage the power of the database behind, by comparison. I can't bring that power into their interfaces (and no, being able to do that
to some degree it's not good enough and it'll never be).
By sheer amount of effort Marcos got the balance right again, between design and functionality.
2) XBMC community and XBMC developers proud themselves at the uber flexibility of the skin engine. But if it takes 27000+ lines of code to get this kind of functionality into a skin I say there's something wrong with the concept. I don't know what, I'm not an expert. I just apply my common sense.
What's one to do on a new skin to repeat the feat? Rewrite 27000+ lines of code? Or copy paste Marco's? What am I to do, who I'm good at Photoshop and I'm not an idiot at XML but still learning about coding skins? The prospect of 27000+ lines of code to get functionality in, it kills my will to live...!
Which gets to my questioning the concept. The devs got the skinning engine really flexible. But what have we given up for that?
Just to be clear, I'm not taking aim at anybody. I'm just looking at things in the grand scheme, which I feel it's a category of discussion that's lacking, between the zillion of small things people ask about.